Blog Layout

Perhaps I was Wrong about Tristan Jarry

Yinzer Crazy • February 24, 2022

Story by Yinzer Crazy Contributor Elliot Hicks. Follow him on Twitter @Ehicks39


Let’s turn back the clock for a moment to last May. I published a story on this very site (https://www.yinzercrazy.com/can-the-pens-win-the-cup-with-tristan-jarry-in-net) that essentially flamed Penguins starting goaltender Tristan Jarry and the rest of the crew, saying that the options in goal were not good enough to win in the Stanley Cup playoffs.


I certainly can’t ignore that, at least at that moment, it was a hot take that paid off extremely well in the short term. Pittsburgh looked off in their playoff series against the New York Islanders and a terrible mistake from Jarry led to the goal that eliminated the Penguins. 


But, as we near the closing stages and playoff push of this season, I’m here with the egg on my face and a nice plate of crow in front of me that I was wrong about the men in goal for the Pens,
specifically the dude wearing No. 35. 


Jarry’s performance this season has been quite strong to say the least. His 2.29 GAA sits at seventh-best in the NHL, fourth-best among goaltenders who have made at least 35 appearances. A .922 save percentage lines up about the same near the top of the NHL leaderboard. Jarry has the fourth-most wins, is tied for the third-most shutouts, and has kept the Penguins in games more often than not with some stellar moments. We can’t forget a solid performance in the All-Star Game, an environment where any sort of save is an impressive one, to lead the Metropolitan team to victory. 


While I didn’t completely write off Jarry as the best option for Pittsburgh in net, I certainly didn’t show any faith in him, and honestly the benefit of the doubt I gave him in that article I didn’t even really believe at the time.

But there’s a reason he was kept around after the first full offseason of the new Hextall/Burke pairing in the front office (even if it was only because the trade and free agency market was essentially just a tumbleweed rolling through the desert.) There’s a reason that he was kept around, even as we thought Marc-Andre Fleury was going to stay forever, and as we thought Matt Murray was going to do the same. 


The kid has talent. He’s always had potential. And he’s one of the best goaltenders in hockey at the moment. Jarry is someone who I think we’ll look back on as a generally solid option in net throughout the latter stages of the current window with a trio of Crosby, Malkin and Letang that’s been together longer than any trio of dudes in league history. 


With all of that said, however, I’m still not all-in until I see more consistency in the playoffs. We’ve had this song and dance before in postseason play between the 2009 and 2016 Cup wins with Fleury. But he had the pedigree of being truly elite at times and having that Cup on his resume. Jarry doesn’t…yet. 


Should Pittsburgh turn down a top-tier option in goal if one becomes available if this postseason goes as poorly as last year’s? Not at all. 


But did Jarry deserve the hammering I gave him last year? Probably not.




Thanks for reading! Make sure to subscribe to Yinzer Crazy on YouTube and listen to the Yinzer Crazy Podcast on your favorite streaming platform. Our most recent guest was former Penguins' GM Craig Patrick.

You might also like

Yinzer Crazy

By Yinzer Crazy February 16, 2025
Story by Yinzer Crazy Contributor Harv Aronson. Contact Harv @ Totalsportsrecall@gmail.com
By Yinzer Crazy February 11, 2025
Story by Yinzer Crazy Contributor Harv Aronson. Contact Harv @ Totalsportsrecall@gmail.com
By Yinzer Crazy January 31, 2025
Story by Yinzer Crazy Contributor Harv Aronson. Contact Harv @ Totalsportsrecall@gmail.com
More Posts

Book a Service Today

Share by: